Mineo's Pizza House
Iconic Squirrel Hill Pizzeria
Pizza by the slice or pie, plus Sicilian and white varieties, subs and pastas in a no-frills space.
2128 Murray Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15217
mineospizza.com

Aiello's Pizza
Classic dishes, including stuffed shells and meatballs, share the menu with pizzas from homemade dough.
2112 Murray Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15217
www.aiellospizza.com
412-521-9973
 
Benny Fierro's
Relaxed counter-serve chain dishing up giant thin-crust, New York-style slices and pies till the wee hours.
1906 E. Carson St., Pittsburgh, PA 15203
bennysva.com/locations/benny-fierros/
412-709-6077

Pizza Milano
Menu boasting a robust list of specialty pies and a make-your-own option, plus pasta and sandwiches.
1304 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15219
pizzamilano.net
412-281-8181

Genoa Pizza and Bar
Counter serve offering a large menu, including subs, wings and pasta, plus pizza by the slice or pie.
111 Market St., Pittsburgh, PA 15222
genoapizza.com
412-281-6100
 
Iron Born Pizza         
Passionate about elevating the quality of pizza by focusing on every ingredient, from the house-made garlic oil to the pickled banana peppers, ingredients are hand-forged into an ever-changing list of inventive pies where flavor and seasonal ingredients are king.
1806 Smallman St., Pittsburgh, PA 15222
ironbornpizza.com
412-588-0094
 
Pizza Taglio
Cozy BYOB eatery where the focus is simple: gourmet Italian pies with crisp, airy crusts. Artisan pies are Roman-inspired, with a light, impossibly airy crust, and each one is big enough to share (if you’re willing to share, that is).
126 S. Highland Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15206
412-404-7410

Pizza Parma 
High-quality pasta selections are all made with special homemade sauces.
217 S. Highland Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15206
pizzaparma.us
412-441-6600

Driftwood Oven
Voted Best Restaurant in Pittsburgh in 2019.
3615 Butler St., Pittsburgh, PA 15201
driftwoodoven.com
412-251-0253

V3 Flatbread Pizza 
A new fast-casual pizza shop where customers can create their own pizza masterpiece. Choose your dough, then your sauce, unlimited toppings and end with seasonings, finishes and oils — all for one low price!
4500 Butler St., Pittsburgh, PA 15201
v3flatbreadpizza.com
412-456-0500
 
Mercurio's Shadyside
This bright, family-owned Italian eatery is known for its homemade gelato and Neapolitan pizza.
5523 Walnut St., Pittsburgh, PA 15232
mercuriosgelatopizza.com
412-621-6220

Badamo's Pizza 
One of the most impressive things about Badamo's is that their Sicilian pies are as equally delicious as their thin-crust pies. It's rare that a place can do both so well.
656 Washington Road, Mount Lebanon, PA 15228
412-563-1000
AND
1106 Federal St., Pittsburgh, PA 15212
www.badamospizza.com
412-231-1001

King Crust
Homemade, flavorful, healthy and stone-baked pizza comes in a variety of crusts. Their pizzas define flavor, lightness, freshness and deliciousness!
1105 Bower Hill Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15243
www.kingcrust.com
412-429-0999

Fiores 
Great service with excellent meals at reasonable prices. We strive to spread the traditional style of Italian cuisine to other areas of town.
103 Capital Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15226
fiorispizzaria.com
412-343-7788

Leone's Pizza
Family-owned pizza shop in Oakmont, PA. Come on down! Leone’s took over What’s Cookin at Casey’s location.
608 Allegheny River Blvd., Oakmont, PA 15139
facebook.com/leonespizzaoakmont
412-828-9507

Veltre's Pizza
New Location: Just up the road
Homemade pizza, gourmet pizza, snacks and appetizers.
5 River Road, Plum, PA 15068
veltrespizza.com
412-828-1421

Bella Notte
Booths line the walls of this relaxed Italian restaurant with an Italian flag-colored ceiling.
1914 Penn Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15222
bellanottepgh.com
412-281-4488